Dear ,
This morning I read about the Civil War—and the excavation of the Boston Common to build an underground parking garage. Those two go together because the Common is the site of a monument that remembers a regiment from, yes, the Civil War.
For the past few days I have been thinking about war of a certain kind. The trampling of tenderness. I venture to call this abuse.
When you grow up like I did, under the roof of an abusive person, you learn the signs, but still—it is hard to keep your heart intact. At the window, you watch for his return, and you wonder…today, will my heart survive? You learn, from having put your heart out there and watching someone delight in the steady march and tread over it—this is a critical question, this one about your heart.
When they excavated the Common to build the garage, apparently they propped up the monument. Remembrance was atilt. In the article I read this morning, in which a poem is shared that says, “Their monument sticks like a fishbone/in the city’s throat,” I’m not sure what question the poet was asking in his poem. (All good poems, in my opinion, ask a question in their way.) If it had been my poem, I think I would pose: Can we survive if we forget this?—it hurts our hearts to hate.
I am convinced that there are (at least) three ways people may move into the world when they live through abuse. There are choices, and it’s not clear to me how we make them. It seems that either we ourselves become a trampler, or we learn to keep our hearts hidden (even in what are safer contexts, later on), or we decipher the secret, somehow, of how to keep our hearts intact and share them wisely.
Recently, I guided my daughters through a difficult conversation. In this micro-moment of civil war, there were choices arising every few minutes. Trample? Hide? Truly, they wanted neither, but they were in need of tools to guide them in this vulnerable and delicate tussle of their hearts. Afterwards, they joked that I had performed the service of conflict resolution. It was amusing, to all of us. But it is not how I picture what happened.
When children, then young adults, are not given the tools of communication navigation, especially to guide them through tender moments where their hearts are exposed, they can grow up to be abusers, or elaborate manipulators. I call this heat without light. Apparently, this is possible. To have heat without light. But I don’t mean to get literal on this count. What I do mean is that the heart is always firing, desiring. And, in the absence of knowing how to handle that fire, we get all heat and no light.
There were times, when my girls were young, that I did not know how to handle the fire. My heart was hurting, or tired. Maybe I said something meanly off-the-cuff to one of them. On rare occasion, I yelled. Either way, the moment asked of me this: repair. It occurred to me one day that it wasn’t good enough to simply apologize to one girl, had the other been there to witness the treading. On that day, I made a decision: I would always apologize to both girls if they’d both been in the room. Because, this too is true—not only does it hurt our hearts to hate…it hurts our hearts to see others hatefully mistreated. The hearts of two girls were therefore in need of being attended to: the one who had suffered, and the one who had witnessed the suffering.
Though I see no problem with conflict itself (it’s simply an invitation to have a difficult conversation), I believe that civil wars and raging fires—of many kinds—are avoidable. I am not sure they are avoidable when they’re agitated by those who are ahead of us in age and authority, those who aim to generate heat but no light.
Still, I remember those days at the window. And the choices they presented my heart over time—trample, hide, or learn?
Wherever you are today, Dear——, whatever window you are looking through, your heart firing within you, I wish you the power to choose the latter. I, for one, promise to stand beside you—to learn, and invite the light.
As Always,
L.L.